• Log In

The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast

A Philosophy Podcast and Philosophy Blog

Subscribe on Android Spotify Google Podcasts audible patreon
  • Home
  • Podcast
    • PEL Network Episodes
    • Publicly Available PEL Episodes
    • Paywalled and Ad-Free Episodes
    • PEL Episodes by Topic
    • Nightcap
    • Philosophy vs. Improv
    • Pretty Much Pop
    • Nakedly Examined Music
    • (sub)Text
    • Phi Fic Podcast
    • Combat & Classics
    • Constellary Tales
  • Blog
  • About
    • PEL FAQ
    • Meet PEL
    • About Pretty Much Pop
    • Philosophy vs. Improv
    • Nakedly Examined Music
    • Meet Phi Fic
    • Listener Feedback
    • Links
  • Join
    • Become a Citizen
    • Join Our Mailing List
    • Log In
  • Donate
  • Store
    • Episodes
    • Swag
    • Everything Else
    • Cart
    • Checkout
    • My Account
  • Contact
  • Mailing List

Ned Block Reviews Damasio’s Latest

November 30, 2010 by Wes Alwan 4 Comments

Ned Block -- whose views on consciousness and the mind-body problem are, like those of David Chalmers, close to my own (and far from those of Daniel C. Dennett) -- is not impressed with Antonio Damasio's new book Self Comes to Mind: Constructing the Conscious Brain.Damasio makes the same sorts of desperate moves typical of those determined to jerry-rig a scientific solution to a philosophical problem: he makes consciousness dependent on self-consciousness (and seems by implication to deny it to animals, despite other claims to the contrary); and rejects the scientific evidence that consciousness does not depend in any way on behavioral manifestations. Unfortunately, it's just a brief review; for a full dose of Block, see his excellent critique of Jerry Fodor's What Darwin Got Wrong.

As far as I'm concerned, attributing "consciousness" to the brain as a property -- as Damasio does in his subtitle -- is the kind of category mistake that would simply prevent me from picking up a book on the subject in the first place. Damasio is (sometimes) conscious. His brain is white and gray, weighs a few pounds, and is composed of neurons. While Damasio's consciousness depends importantly on Damasio's brain, calling this a property of the brain in some typical sense simply seems wrong to me. Calling the brain "consciousness-causing" I think would be closer to the truth; better still would be to talk about a relation -- such as supervenience -- between two sets of properties. But then again all of this goes for identity theories of mind as well: for such theories mental states are at least token identical with brain states. Regardless of my theory, I would never say the brain processes involved in looking at a red apple are themselves conscious of a red apple. This may all seem like a quibble, but I think calling the brain conscious leads the sorts of confusions that pervade popular books on this subject and popular talk about it -- including the idea that the brain "makes decisions."

-Wes Alwan

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

Filed Under: Web Detritus Tagged With: consciousness, damasio, ned block, philosophy blog, philosophy of mind

Comments

  1. w says

    December 10, 2010 at 10:08 pm

    Argh, there seems to be something wrong with the comments.

    Reply
  2. Karl Miller says

    April 26, 2013 at 10:07 am

    Since you guys are willing to spend time on Dennett, live to regret it, and then spend more time on Dennett, may I ask if you’ve ever come across Julian Jaynes, even just to swat him down? I find his name nowhere on your site, but his grand 1976 book gets a jab by Block in the link above and seems relevant to so many of your discussions of selfhood and consciousness.

    I recently discovered the Jaynes book and have been searching for a definitive take down of his theory, which led me to Block, whose objections fail to persuade. Block’s rebuke in the link above is just hearsay and it doesn’t jive with the Jaynesian inquiry, as I understand it. In any case, since you seem willing to dip into more popular fare like “Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance” and the shelf of neo-atheist garbage, maybe you’d consider bundling some of Jaynes into the discussion sometime?

    Reply
    • Mark Linsenmayer says

      April 26, 2013 at 12:51 pm

      Hi, Karl,

      Yes, I have the Jaynes book sitting on my shelf, though I can’t recall at this point if I ever read any of it. Certainly I’m familiar with the thesis and would not mind reading this at some point. I think an episode with essays by Block and others is more likely, though. We’ve got to get back into mind somehow w/in the next six months…

      -Mark

      Reply
  3. Karl Miller says

    April 26, 2013 at 3:28 pm

    That would be lovely. You can get quite a lot out of the first few chapters of Jaynes (what constitutes Book One) — at least enough to start arguing about. And he’s a fluid and supple writer to boot. It would bundle easily with Block or someone else on a related subject. I know he fell out of fashion, but I still haven’t found a thorough counter-argument for his theory. Your podcasts on Lacan, Sartre Block’s “p-consciousness” and “a-consciousness” strikes me as a fruitless formulation, so I await an episode on him.

    Keep up the great work, gentlemen. I’ve been drinking up the archive hour by hour. Have you considered transcribing them via Mechanical Turk or some such? Might cost some money up front, but would then turn into another merchandising opportunity, so … run it by the PEL exchequer, please.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

PEL Live Show 2023

Brothers K Live Show

Citizenship has its Benefits

Become a PEL Citizen
Become a PEL Citizen, and get access to all paywalled episodes, early and ad-free, including exclusive Part 2's for episodes starting September 2020; our after-show Nightcap, where the guys respond to listener email and chat more causally; a community of fellow learners, and more.

Rate and Review

Nightcap

Listen to Nightcap
On Nightcap, listen to the guys respond to listener email and chat more casually about their lives, the making of the show, current events and politics, and anything else that happens to come up.

Subscribe to Email Updates

Select list(s):

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Support PEL

Buy stuff through Amazon and send a few shekels our way at no extra cost to you.

Tweets by PartiallyExLife

Recent Comments

  • Seth Paskin on PEL Eulogies Nightcap Late March 2023
  • John Heath on PEL Eulogies Nightcap Late March 2023
  • Randy Strader on Ep. 309: Wittgenstein On Certainty (Part Two)
  • Wes Alwan on PEL Nightcap February 2023
  • Kunal on Why Don’t We Like Idealism?

About The Partially Examined Life

The Partially Examined Life is a philosophy podcast by some guys who were at one point set on doing philosophy for a living but then thought better of it. Each episode, we pick a text and chat about it with some balance between insight and flippancy. You don’t have to know any philosophy, or even to have read the text we’re talking about to (mostly) follow and (hopefully) enjoy the discussion

Become a PEL Citizen!

As a PEL Citizen, you’ll have access to a private social community of philosophers, thinkers, and other partial examiners where you can join or initiate discussion groups dedicated to particular readings, participate in lively forums, arrange online meet-ups for impromptu seminars, and more. PEL Citizens also have free access to podcast transcripts, guided readings, episode guides, PEL music, and other citizen-exclusive material. Click here to join.

Blog Post Categories

  • (sub)Text
  • Aftershow
  • Announcements
  • Audiobook
  • Book Excerpts
  • Citizen Content
  • Citizen Document
  • Citizen News
  • Close Reading
  • Combat and Classics
  • Constellary Tales
  • Exclude from Newsletter
  • Featured Ad-Free
  • Featured Article
  • General Announcements
  • Interview
  • Letter to the Editor
  • Misc. Philosophical Musings
  • Nakedly Examined Music Podcast
  • Nakedly Self-Examined Music
  • NEM Bonus
  • Not School Recording
  • Not School Report
  • Other (i.e. Lesser) Podcasts
  • PEL Music
  • PEL Nightcap
  • PEL's Notes
  • Personal Philosophies
  • Phi Fic Podcast
  • Philosophy vs. Improv
  • Podcast Episode (Citizen)
  • Podcast Episodes
  • Pretty Much Pop
  • Reviewage
  • Song Self-Exam
  • Supporter Exclusive
  • Things to Watch
  • Vintage Episode (Citizen)
  • Web Detritus

Follow:

Twitter | Facebook | Google+ | Apple Podcasts

Copyright © 2009 - 2023 · The Partially Examined Life, LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Copyright Policy

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in