In the recent Frege episode, Mark related the famous anecdote of how Bertrand Russell, the man who "discovered" Frege, later confounded him by pointing out a paradox apparent within his logical system. As Wes recounted, Russell's own attempt to ground mathematics in logic was also later frustrated by a young Kurt Gödel, whose early incompleteness theorems crippled the central purpose of Principia Mathematica.
Anyway, those of us who suffer nausea upon seeing the character ∀ can nevertheless relive those heady days with Logicomix. A comic book about the quest for absolute logical certainty makes an unlikely choice for an award-winning New York Times bestseller, but I must say its an entertaining read. To steal a brief recap from the NYT book review:
The story spans the decades from the late 19th century to World War II, a period when the nature of mathematical truth was being furiously debated. The stellar cast, headed up by Bertrand Russell, includes the greatest philosophers, logicians and mathematicians of the era, along with sundry wives and mistresses, plus a couple of homicidal maniacs, an apocryphal barber and Adolf Hitler.
Spoiler alert, per Seth: "Founding anything always fails."
-Daniel Horne
Wes Alwan says
March 23, 2011 at 12:22 pmtoo cool; had to purchase
Daniel Horne says
March 23, 2011 at 2:20 pmCool, Wes, I hope you dig it.
Anyone who wants to sample a few pages before committing can click on the NYT multimedia excerpt here:
http://documents.nytimes.com/logicomix-excerpt
Warning: This is not “logic for dummies,” which at the beginning I was half-hoping for. But it contains a few useful graphic illustrations of logical problems.
Nor is it a perfectly accurate history, as it takes a number of liberties for the sake of narrative. But it’s true enough, and — more to the point — a fun tour of an exciting era in logic, mathematics, and philosophy. We talked earlier about how philosophical concepts could benefit from graphic illustration, and I think this is Exhibit A in support.
Now if we could just get Frank Miller to illustrate Being revealing itself as itself…