• Log In

The Partially Examined Life Philosophy Podcast

A Philosophy Podcast and Philosophy Blog

Subscribe on Android Spotify Google Podcasts audible patreon
  • Home
  • Podcast
    • PEL Network Episodes
    • Publicly Available PEL Episodes
    • Paywalled and Ad-Free Episodes
    • PEL Episodes by Topic
    • Nightcap
    • (sub)Text
    • Pretty Much Pop
    • Nakedly Examined Music
    • Phi Fic Podcast
    • Combat & Classics
    • Constellary Tales
  • Blog
  • About
    • PEL FAQ
    • Meet PEL
    • About Pretty Much Pop
    • Nakedly Examined Music
    • Meet Phi Fic
    • Listener Feedback
    • Links
  • Join
    • Become a Citizen
    • Join Our Mailing List
    • Log In
  • Donate
  • Store
    • Episodes
    • Swag
    • Everything Else
    • Cart
    • Checkout
    • My Account
  • Contact
  • Mailing List

Ep. 225: Simone Weil on War and Oppression (Part One)

September 9, 2019 by Mark Linsenmayer 5 Comments

https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.libsyn.com/secure/partiallyexaminedlife/PEL_ep_225pt1_8-18-19.mp3

Podcast: Play in new window | Download (Duration: 47:16 — 43.3MB)

On Simone Weil's essays "The Iliad, or the Poem of Force" (1939) and "Analysis of Oppression" (1934).

How do circumstances oppress and dehumanize us? Weil describes the mechanisms that keep people at war and maintain oppression even through revolutions (the new boss tends to be as bad as the old boss) as inherent to the logic of power.

She uses Homer's Iliad to illustrate this picture of war: Force, the real hero of the epic, dehumanizes both its victims and perpetrators. When an aggressor has someone helpless and on their knees, the latter becomes no longer a human whose needs need to be recognized but an object that can be destroyed on a whim. One might think that this would be the time for magnanimity, but that would require recognition, and this is typically no longer available for an aggressor whose humanity is also being sapped by the situation.

At many points in the Iliad, one or the other side is at an advantage and could with some mild concessions stop the war, but the power makes the current victors feel invulnerable, and they feel they've already sacrificed too much to settle for anything less than total destruction of the enemy. Having your fellows die brings out a nihilistic attitude in the survivors, a drive toward death for all concerned that precludes both self-preservation and mercy. And so the war grinds on.

In "Analysis of Oppression," a similar vicious circle is at play in the logic of economic domination. Weil revises Hobbes's picture of the state of nature: We are in nature oppressed by the forces of necessity, of having to keep from starving, but when society forms, we could theoretically be freed from this burden, but it instead shifts from oppression directly by nature to oppression by other people, which is really just nature asserting itself indirectly. Cooperative production essentially requires that some small group be the ones who understand the social structure and its tools and hence are able to issue the commands. Weil admires Karl Marx for identifying that it's the structure of capitalism that is responsible for the oppression, not the individual capitalists, but thinks that Marxists are foolish to think that a revolution can fix this. In Russia, for instance, it's not the case that the weaker (the workers) overcame the stronger (the Czarist government), but that the already-weak Czarists were displaced by industrial forces that already had de facto power. The weak by definition can't overcome the strong; power dynamics are created by material conditions, and apparent revolutions are just going to be shifts from one declining power center to an ascending one.

Guest Corey Mohler, writer of Existential Comics, rejoins Mark, Wes, Dylan, and Seth (check out his previous appearance) to tackle this fascinating figure who was a major influence on Albert Camus. He assures us that even though both essays that we read here seem very pessimistic, she in fact does write elsewhere about positive solutions, though they do have to do with her Christian mysticism, so maybe you don't want to read about that.

Get both essays and follow the page numbers we refer to in Simone Weil an Anthology (Penguin Modern Classics). You should be able to easily find an online copy of Weil's "The Iliad, or the Poem of Force," and I see that "Analysis of Oppression" is in also in this volume.

Continues with part two; get the full, ad-free Citizen Edition now. Please support PEL!

Image by Solomon Grundy.

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

Filed Under: Podcast Episodes Tagged With: philosophy of war, philosophy podcast, political philosophy, Simone Weil

Comments

  1. Peter Linton says

    September 9, 2019 at 12:05 pm

    Love the “Lennon” take

    Reply
  2. dmf says

    September 9, 2019 at 2:41 pm

    hmm pessimism or realism, she doesn’t seem to have found a way out of her own lived situation that one would characterize as positive even in the lights of the death/sacrifice cults of christian mysticism…

    Reply
  3. Phil says

    September 11, 2019 at 3:58 am

    Really good episode on a fascinating and underappreciated philosopher. The analysis of power you described from Weil reminded me of ‘The Children of Light and the Children of Darkness’ by Reinhold Neibuhr,

    His defence of democracy is based not in ‘liberal’ philosophy, but on a pessimism of human nature and an analysis of societal power structures having their own inescapable internal logic which would seem to fit well with what you describe of Weil’s analysis.

    Reply
  4. Luis Fernando Arean Alvarez says

    September 16, 2019 at 2:03 pm

    Just a quick comment concerning your summary in your Existential Comics page. It makes the common mistake of interpreting the Theory of Evolution as the survival of the strongest. That’s innacurate. The strongest species can be destroyed by a virus. It is the survival of the FITTEST:

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Force, the True Master of War : Simone Weil’s The Iliad or, The Poem of Force – Working Title Bookshop says:
    September 26, 2019 at 11:12 am

    […] Examined Life’s discussion of the essay, as well as some of Weil’s other work (Part 1, Part […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Force, the True Master of War : Simone Weil’s The Iliad or, The Poem of Force – Working Title Bookshop Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Citizenship has its Benefits

Become a PEL Citizen
Become a PEL Citizen, and get access to all paywalled episodes, early and ad-free, including exclusive Part 2's for episodes starting September 2020; our after-show Nightcap, where the guys respond to listener email and chat more causally; a community of fellow learners, and more.

Rate and Review

Nightcap

Listen to Nightcap
On Nightcap, listen to the guys respond to listener email and chat more casually about their lives, the making of the show, current events and politics, and anything else that happens to come up.

Subscribe to Email Updates

Select list(s):

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Support PEL

Buy stuff through Amazon and send a few shekels our way at no extra cost to you.

Tweets by PartiallyExLife

Recent Comments

  • Daniel Gustafsson on Shakespeare’s “Timon of Athens” Audioplay (Part Two for Supporters)
  • B F on Ep. 298: Marsilio Ficino on Love (Part One)
  • Kris on Combat & Classics Ep. 58 Homer’s “Iliad” Book 1
  • Nietzsche on Dance Lessons with Nietzsche
  • Marty on Douglas Hofstadter’s “I Am a Strange Loop” on the Self

About The Partially Examined Life

The Partially Examined Life is a philosophy podcast by some guys who were at one point set on doing philosophy for a living but then thought better of it. Each episode, we pick a text and chat about it with some balance between insight and flippancy. You don’t have to know any philosophy, or even to have read the text we’re talking about to (mostly) follow and (hopefully) enjoy the discussion

Become a PEL Citizen!

As a PEL Citizen, you’ll have access to a private social community of philosophers, thinkers, and other partial examiners where you can join or initiate discussion groups dedicated to particular readings, participate in lively forums, arrange online meet-ups for impromptu seminars, and more. PEL Citizens also have free access to podcast transcripts, guided readings, episode guides, PEL music, and other citizen-exclusive material. Click here to join.

Blog Post Categories

  • (sub)Text
  • Aftershow
  • Announcements
  • Audiobook
  • Book Excerpts
  • Citizen Content
  • Citizen Document
  • Citizen News
  • Close Reading
  • Combat and Classics
  • Constellary Tales
  • Exclude from Newsletter
  • Featured Ad-Free
  • Featured Article
  • General Announcements
  • Interview
  • Letter to the Editor
  • Misc. Philosophical Musings
  • Nakedly Examined Music Podcast
  • Nakedly Self-Examined Music
  • NEM Bonus
  • Not School Recording
  • Not School Report
  • Other (i.e. Lesser) Podcasts
  • PEL Music
  • PEL Nightcap
  • PEL's Notes
  • Personal Philosophies
  • Phi Fic Podcast
  • Philosophy vs. Improv
  • Podcast Episode (Citizen)
  • Podcast Episodes
  • Pretty Much Pop
  • Reviewage
  • Song Self-Exam
  • Supporter Exclusive
  • Things to Watch
  • Vintage Episode (Citizen)
  • Web Detritus

Follow:

Twitter | Facebook | Google+ | Apple Podcasts

Copyright © 2009 - 2022 · The Partially Examined Life, LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Copyright Policy

Copyright © 2022 · Magazine Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in