David Hume’s influence is felt throughout Anglophone philosophy, most especially in epistemology. Typically, students and scholars of Hume’s epistemology focus on whether judgments and sentiments, among other considerations, can count as knowledge. For normative judgments, this focus leads to thorny questions about grounding, truthmaking, and non-cognitivism. This is rough Continue Reading …
Ep. 368: Hume on Reason in Ethics (Part Two)
Subscribe to get parts 1 and 2 of this now, ad-free, plus tons of bonus content. We conclude our discussion of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739): Book III, "Of Morals," plus a bit more discussion of An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751). Listen to part one first, or better yet, start with ep. 367. How do moral sentiments fit into Hume's overall Continue Reading …
Ep. 368: Hume on Reason in Ethics (Part One)
Subscribe to get parts 1 and 2 of this now, ad-free, plus tons of bonus content. Continuing our treatment from ep. 367, we talk a bit more about David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751), specifically on the conclusion and Appendix I, "Concerning Moral Sentiment," and add some parts of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739): sec. 3 "Of the Influencing Continue Reading …
Ep. 368: Hume on Reason in Ethics (Part Two for Supporters)
We conclude our discussion of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739): Book III, "Of Morals," plus a bit more discussion of An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751). Listen to part one first, or better yet, start with ep. 367. How do moral sentiments fit into Hume's overall philosophy of mind? Hume famously our conscious experience to be composed solely of impressions Continue Reading …
Ep. 368: Hume on Reason in Ethics (Part One for Supporters)
Continuing our treatment from ep. 367, we talk a bit more about David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751), specifically on the conclusion and Appendix I, "Concerning Moral Sentiment," and add some parts of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739): sec. 3 "Of the Influencing Motives of the Will" within the third part of Book II, "Of the Passions," and the first Continue Reading …
Ep. 367: Hume on the Foundations of Ethics (Part Two)
Subscribe to get parts 1 and 2 of this now, ad-free, plus tons of bonus content. Continuing from part one on An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751). We dive into ch. 2 on justice: Hume says that the idea of property is not natural, but is an artificial construct created for utilitarian purposes. This means that property laws will be different in different Continue Reading …
Ep. 367: Hume on the Foundations of Ethics (Part One)
Subscribe to get parts 1 and 2 of this now, ad-free, plus tons of bonus content. On David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751), featuring Mark, Wes, Dylan, and Seth. What is morality, and how can we know it? Sponsor: Get a $1/month e-commerce trial at shopify.com/pel. We've been discussing the bases of morality of late: Are fundamental Continue Reading …
Ep. 367: Hume on the Foundations of Ethics (Part Two for Supporters)
Continuing from part one on An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751). We dive into ch. 2 on justice: Hume says that the idea of property is not natural, but is an artificial construct created for utilitarian purposes. This means that property laws will be different in different societies based on what is scarce enough to require regulation and protection. Hume's Continue Reading …
Ep. 367: Hume on the Foundations of Ethics (Part One for Supporters)
On David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751), featuring Mark, Wes, Dylan, and Seth. What is morality, and how can we know it? We've been discussing the bases of morality of late: Are fundamental principles revealed to us by reason (perhaps "rational intuition"), or by sentiment (e.g. our feelings of empathy with others. Hume is a chief voice in the Continue Reading …
Why You Don’t Exist
I’m very sorry to inform you that I have some bad news. Well, maybe not bad per se, but I think you might find it a little disturbing. You might want to make sure you’re sitting down for this. Ready? Okay, here goes: You might not exist. I know, I know. It’s okay. I understand that it’s difficult to accept. But the sooner you make peace with it, the better. You’ll see. With Continue Reading …
The Life of the Volunteer
David Hume said, "Be a philosopher; but amidst all your philosophy, be still a man." The thing is, studying philosophy may or may not have an effect on your life. Even if it does, people usually follow Hume's advice to compartmentalize. Meta-ethics is typical of philosophy here. Moral skeptics often clarify that they're motivated by all the right ethical principles, but Continue Reading …
What’s the Deal with Why?
Philip Goff’s Why? lays out the case for cosmic purpose built into the universe from the very beginning, thereby showing our own lives to be imbued with meaning. It’s a bold work, touching on heady ideas like fine-tuning of the universe, the nature of probability, consciousness, and more. But the main idea remains - we can derive deep meaning and value in our lives, as we’re a Continue Reading …
Closereads: Hume on Passions (Part One)
Sign up for Closereads at patreon.com/closereadsphilosophy to get additional parts of this reading, as well as our previous and future installments of this new podcast. On Book II of A Treatise of Human Nature (1739), this time reading sections 1 and 2 in Part I, "Pride and Humility." How does David Hume deal with human emotions, given his empiricism that begins with the Continue Reading …
Ep. 289: Aesthetic Sense Theory: Shaftesbury, Hutcheson, Hume (Part One)
Subscribe to get Part 2 of this episode. Listen to a preview. Hear this part ad-free. On David Hume's "The Standard of Taste" (1760) and its two main influences: The Moralists: A Philosophical Rhapsody (1709) by Anthony Ashley-Cooper, aka the third Earl of Shaftesbury, Part III section 2 "Beauty," and An Inquiry Concerning Beauty, Order, Harmony, Design (1725) by Continue Reading …
Ep. 289: Aesthetic Sense Theory: Hume (Part Two for Supporters)
Continuing from part one, we get into more detail on David Hume's "The Standard of Taste" (1760). Hume starts out with a paradox: On the one hand, we believe that beauty is in the eye of the beholder; it's not a property of objects but of the interaction between an object and an observer. On the other hand, some works are obviously, objectively more beautiful than others, Continue Reading …
Ep. 289: Aesthetic Sense Theory: Shaftesbury, Hutcheson, Hume (Part One for Supporters)
On David Hume's "The Standard of Taste" (1760) and its two main influences: The Moralists: A Philosophical Rhapsody (1709) by Anthony Ashley-Cooper, aka the third Earl of Shaftesbury, Part III section 2 "Beauty," and An Inquiry Concerning Beauty, Order, Harmony, Design (1725) by Francis Hutcheson. Featuring Mark, Wes, Dylan, and Seth. How do we know what opinions about Continue Reading …
Episode 167: Hume on Intelligent Design (Part Two)
Continuing on David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779), with guest Stephen West. We get further into what's wrong with the design argument and why Hume thinks that it's merely a verbal dispute whether we want to say that God designed the orderly universe or just say that the universe is orderly. Also, the problem of evil! Listen to part 1 first, or get the Continue Reading …
Episode 167: Hume on Intelligent Design (Part One)
On David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779). How would a scientifically minded person argue for God's existence? In Hume's dialogue, a character named Cleanthes argues from this point of view for God's existence based on the complexity and order apparent in nature: It looks designed. But how good is that argument, and is it enough to prove an infinite God of Continue Reading …
Ep. 167: Hume on Intelligent Design (Philosophize This! Crossover) (Citizen Edition)
On David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779). How would a scientifically minded person argue for the existence of God? In Hume's dialogue, a character named Cleanthes argues from this point of view for God's existence based on the complexity and order apparent in nature: It looks designed. But how good is that argument, and is it enough to prove an infinite God Continue Reading …
Hume on Religion: A Video Introduction to PEL Ep. 167
Here's the topic announcement/summary introduction (i.e. a precognition) for our next episode, introducing Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. Watch on YouTube. The text here is the introduction I'll actually lead off the episode recording itself with, just as Wes just did on #166 on Spinoza. We're interested in hearing from you, both regarding whether you Continue Reading …
Inverting the Gaze: Pagan Political Philosophy
[From Michael Burgess, edited by Seth.] A traditional means of founding political or moral philosophies in the west has been the construction of a point from which we can be seen and judged. This is an internalization and politicization of the Christian God who surveys and intervenes in his creation: we are always under the gaze of God and must therefore be Good. For Hume this Continue Reading …
Why can’t life always be beautiful?
[A blog post from friend of PEL Phillip C. It's a bit longer than our normal posts and is heavy with the name drops but I'm going to let it go because it's on art, is related to a discussion group and I make the editing decisions around here - Seth] “What strikes me is the fact that in our society, art has become something which is related only to objects and not to Continue Reading …
Cognitive and Affective Empathy in Moral Sentiment
[DISCLAIMER: Although I am using a conceptual distinction I got from the embedded Simon Baron-Cohen TEDx talk (where ever he got it from), I am not taking a position on his stance on Autism or Psychopathy. I have no point of view about Autism and have reflected on empathy and psychopathy in this blog before, here and here. I'm interested in the constituent parts of empathy Continue Reading …
The Leap of Faith: The Creative Element of Science
[Editor's Note: Thanks to new contributor Rob Graumans for this one!] Scientific realists are known to have a positive epistemic attitude towards the content of our best scientific theories and models. The exact interpretation of this philosophical tenet can, however, differ dramatically between each of its proponents. Some of these base their idea of the truthfulness of Continue Reading …
A Theological Summary (and Condemnation) of Emotivism
This video by "Theologica37," part of a "failure of secular ethics" series, makes a decent stab at tracing emotivist tendencies through Continue Reading …
No Self, but a Subject?
At one time in Savatthi, the venerable Radha seated himself and asked of the Blessed Lord Buddha: “Anatta, anatta I hear said, Venerable. What, pray tell, does Anatta mean?” “Just this, Radha, form is not the self (anatta), sensations are not the self (anatta), perceptions are not the self (anatta), assemblages are not the self (anatta), consciousness is not the self (anatta). Continue Reading …
Peter Kail’s Hume Overview on the Elucidations Podcast
Folks looking for a clear, concise Hume review with some nice additional details after our epistemology and ethics episodes on him would benefit from this Elucidations episode featuring Oxford Lecturer Peter Kail. Kail gives a more comprehensive biography than we did, covers induction (note that we also discussed this issue a bit on our Nelson Goodman epsiode), reason, Continue Reading …
David Hume and Adam Smith in the Context of Eighteenth-Century Moral Philosophy, Part 2
As mentioned in my previous entry, moral philosophy in the eighteenth century was principally concerned with three issues: “the selfish hypothesis,” the nature of moral judgment, and the character of moral virtue. This entry regards the second component: the debate between the rationalists and sentimentalists over the nature and justification of moral judgment. Moral Continue Reading …
Amartya Sen on Hume on Ethics
http://youtu.be/_UzWcWaKo88 Watch on YouTube. This video records Nobel laureate Amartya Sen's somewhat rambling lecture, wherein he discusses a few themes in Hume's ethical work which he deems relevant today. Specifically, Sen wants to advocate for Hume's argument that society's globalization tends to expand its moral sensitivities. We hear that Hume was among the first Continue Reading …
David Hume and Adam Smith in the Context of Eighteenth-Century Moral Philosophy, Part 1
Moral philosophy in the eighteenth century was principally concerned with three issues. First, was “the selfish hypothesis,” which maintained that all declarations of public interest were ultimately expressions of private interest. Second, was the explanation and justification of moral judgment. And third, was the character of moral virtue. The selfish hypothesis, though Continue Reading …
Episode 45: Moral Sense Theory: Hume and Smith (Citizens Only)
Discussing parts of David Hume's Treatise of Human Nature (1740) and Adam Smith’s The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759). Where do we get our moral ideas? Hume and Smith both thought that we get them by reflecting on our own moral judgments and on how we and others (including imaginary, hypothesized others) in turn judge those judgments. Mark, Wes, Seth, and guest Getty Lustila, Continue Reading …
PREVIEW-Episode 45: Moral Sense Theory: Hume and Smith
This is a 33-minute preview of our vintage 1 hr, 46-minute episode. Buy Now Purchase this episode for $2.99. Or become a PEL Citizen for $5 a month, and get access to this and all other paywalled episodes, including 68 back catalogue episodes; exclusive Part 2's for episodes published after September, 2020; and our after-show Nightcap, where the guys respond to listener email Continue Reading …
Topic for #45: Moral Sense Theory: Hume and Smith
Here's the recorded episode. In Ep. 41, we discussed David Hume's ethics both providing a challenge for any naturalist (meaning one compatible with a modern scientific world-view) ethics--you can't deduce "ought" from "is"--and as providing an approach to moral psychology. In this discussion, we grappled with selections from Hume’s Treatise of Human Nature (1740) and Adam Continue Reading …
Hume on Miracles Revisited
Chapter 1 of the Mackie book covers Hume's account of miracles, which we discussed in our Hume epistemology episode. One of our blog commenters here mentioned offhand that he thought that argument had been long discredited, which was a surprise to me. You can review the argument at Wikipedia here. Basically it boils down to "extraordinary claims require extraordinary Continue Reading …
Episode 41: Pat Churchland on the Neurobiology of Morality, Plus Hume’s Ethics (Citizens Only)
We spoke with Patricia Churchland after reading her new book Braintrust: What Neuroscience Tells Us About Morality. We also discussed David Hume's ethics as foundational to her work, reading his Treatise on Human Nature (1739), Book III, Part I and his Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals (1751), Section V, Parts I and II. What does the physiology of the brain have to do Continue Reading …
PREVIEW-Episode 41: Pat Churchland on the Neurobiology of Morality (Plus Hume’s Ethics)
This is a 33-minute preview of a 1 hr, 45-minute episode. Buy Now Purchase this episode for $2.99. Or become a PEL Citizen for $5 a month, and get access to this and all other paywalled episodes, including 68 back catalogue episodes; exclusive Part 2's for episodes published after September, 2020; and our after-show Nightcap, where the guys respond to listener email and chat Continue Reading …
Topic for #41: Pat Churchland on the Neurobiology of Morality (Plus Hume’s Ethics)
With special Guest Pat Churchland herself! What does the physiology of the brain have to do with ethics? We were contacted by Pat Churchland's publisher and invited to speak with her about her new book Braintrust: What Neuroscience Tells Us about Morality. She was good enough to chat with us (Mark and Dylan) for a full, regular length show yesterday, and not only about her Continue Reading …
Topic for #41: Pat Churchland on the Neurobiology of Morality (Plus Hume’s Ethics)
With special Guest Pat Churchland herself! Listen to the episode. What does the physiology of the brain have to do with ethics? We were contacted by Pat Churchland's publisher and invited to speak with her about her new book Braintrust: What Neuroscience Tells Us about Morality. She was good enough to chat with us (Mark and Dylan) for a full, regular length show Continue Reading …
Happy Birthday David Hume!
This month lots of people are celebrating David Hume's 300th birthday, including our friends at The Philosopher's Zone and Philosophy Bites. Both have dedicated a series of podcasts to this most important thinker in our tradition and if you aren't a Humeophile or don't know that much about him, I'd definitely recommend checking out their special episodes. Did you know that Continue Reading …
Episode 17: Hume’s Empiricism: What Can We Know? (Citizens Only)
On David Hume's An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding (1748). David Hume thinks that all we can know are our own impressions, i.e. what our moment-to-moment experiences tell us. Funny thing, though: he thinks that no experience shows us one event causing another event. We only experience one thing happening, then another, and these sequences tend to display a lot of Continue Reading …
PREVIEW-Episode 17: Hume’s Empiricism: What Can We Know?
This is a 31-minute preview a vintage 2 hr, 5-minute episode. Buy Now Purchase this episode for $2.99. Or become a PEL Citizen for $5 a month, and get access to this and all other paywalled episodes, including 68 back catalogue episodes; exclusive Part 2's for episodes published after September, 2020; and our after-show Nightcap, where the guys respond to listener email and Continue Reading …

















